A new study has come out saying that young girls are influenced more by friends than media images when it comes to poor body image issues. The article goes on to explain that Texas A & M International University found that body issues come from peer competition, which in turn can be influenced by the media but isn’t the direct cause. I’ve always been a strong believer that the media is largely to blame for our feeling of insecurities, but after reading the research I’m convinced that it may be our friends who influence us. It might not always be intentional but I think friends encourage us to think and feel a certain way so we can belong. I think if you have a friend who criticizes you and makes you feel unsure about yourself it’s time to move on. Maybe we don’t need better bodies, we need better friends. New Research from Texas A & M International University has found that teen girls’ social groups play a bigger role in creating body image issues than television or social media use.
This new research is helping to answer questions in a long running debate about the medias influence on eating disorders. Currently, most ED experts are divided into two camps, those that believe the media plays a significant role in peoples body image issues and those that believe it plays a much smaller role in body image issues.
This debate has already had wide ranging impacts including the banning of thinsparation and similar content on tumblr, Pinterest and other social media. There has even been a complete ban on underweight models in Israel to try and curb the medias influence on young girls and women.
The results of the study show that neither social media usage nor television were tied to body image issues. Seeing thin or “ideal” people in these mediums was also not linked to an increase in eating disorders.
The authors conclude, “Our results suggest that only peer competition, not television or social media use, predict negative outcomes for body image. This suggests that peer competition is more salient to body and eating issues in teenage girls. However, social media use may provide a new arena for peer competition, even if it does not directly influence negative body outcomes.”
These results, which were based on studying 237 young Hispanic women provide some of the first insight into how girls and teens form body image issues.
These findings could help provide a better understanding of how EDs and body image issues begin. They also show that, while banning things like thinspration may still be a good idea, a ban may not actually prevent anyone from developing an ED.
This new research is helping to answer questions in a long running debate about the medias influence on eating disorders. Currently, most ED experts are divided into two camps, those that believe the media plays a significant role in peoples body image issues and those that believe it plays a much smaller role in body image issues.
This debate has already had wide ranging impacts including the banning of thinsparation and similar content on tumblr, Pinterest and other social media. There has even been a complete ban on underweight models in Israel to try and curb the medias influence on young girls and women.
The results of the study show that neither social media usage nor television were tied to body image issues. Seeing thin or “ideal” people in these mediums was also not linked to an increase in eating disorders.
The authors conclude, “Our results suggest that only peer competition, not television or social media use, predict negative outcomes for body image. This suggests that peer competition is more salient to body and eating issues in teenage girls. However, social media use may provide a new arena for peer competition, even if it does not directly influence negative body outcomes.”
These results, which were based on studying 237 young Hispanic women provide some of the first insight into how girls and teens form body image issues.
These findings could help provide a better understanding of how EDs and body image issues begin. They also show that, while banning things like thinspration may still be a good idea, a ban may not actually prevent anyone from developing an ED.